[GTB]

everything is a potential instrument, everything potentially has a 'voice' in music.  Would we want to deter Sigur Ross? Joe Satriani? John Williams, Kraftwerk, Mozart etc?  A picture can paint a thousand words - so can a 'noise'
GTB

[Kafla]

Ha ha - I keep trying to defend what I said - even though I clarified that I was talking about the mad grunts , add ons that some singers do to fill lines

Yes oh and ass are good when used in a hook - America , Razorlight is one of my favs - Oh Oh Oh, Oh
There's trouble in America
Oh Oh Oh, Oh

And my point GTB about synthesisers was exactly the opposite from the point you are making - the voice is the only ' instrument ' that can do words justice so why not use words ?

Yes everything you have said is correct - but I didn't mean that the voice wasn't an instrument - it's just the only instrument capable of pronouncing words

I am positive a song with Steve Hawkins singing would be sh!te 

You sh@g one sheep eh

[cena69]

haha
your really regreting saying that now,
youll definetly think twice about saying things like that

[Kafla]

haha
your really regreting saying that now,
youll definetly think twice about saying things like that

Ha ha

Its so funny I think - everyone getting so sanctimonious about ohs and aas 

for the avoidance of doubt that was a joke 

[seriousfun]

I have a friend who is a mime, I am thinking of using him as the lead vocal on my next track.

[Kafla]

I have a friend who is a mime, I am thinking of using him as the lead vocal on my next track.

ha ha ha ha