The Songwriter Forum - songwriting reviews, tips and chat

Songwriter Forum => Feedback on Finished songs => Topic started by: ABeautifulVirus on December 02, 2012, 08:45:49 PM

Title: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: ABeautifulVirus on December 02, 2012, 08:45:49 PM
hi ya'll. been a while. hoping my schedule changes back so i can get on here more :)

power trio live track w/ one vocal harmony overdub in choruses.
playing a jaguar through vintage tube ampeg VT22 w/ flanger pedal
singing a little flat in some places 'cause i was inside the cans to hear myself next to Rob's drums

Daren Thomas Turner: guitars, vocals
Rob Wilson: drums
Daniel Denial: bass

EXTINCT
© Daren Thomas Turner /MRI © Forever


i am just inbetween my hating
and i just want to be with my baby
and i don't want to die, so save me
don't hang me out to dry, and stab me

could i stay here tonight, for just a little,
it's cold outside my dear
if you say it's alright, i need your shelter
but bury me if you go

i am just inbetween my hatred
and i just want to be with my baby
and i don't want to cry, so save me
don't hang me out to dry, and stab me

could i stay here tonight, for just a little,
it's cold outside my dear
if you say it's alright, i need your shelter
but bury me if you go


http://soundcloud.com/abeautifulvirus/extinct

Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: digger72 on December 02, 2012, 10:13:30 PM
Hi,

Liked that a lot. All dark and brooding. Good vocal style. I liked the weird harmonies. Throw in the modulation sounds and I'm in my element. Maybe a little too muddied at times, but as a live take - loved it.

Will be looking out for more of the same.

Digger
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: S.T.C on December 02, 2012, 10:44:42 PM
Welcome back.. ;)

Like it...The Cure comes to mind...as a comparison ....good stuff.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: Binladeda on December 02, 2012, 11:33:12 PM
 ABV  ..welcome back ;D ;D....Like this, took me back a few years ;D  nice 'acid' feel about it,  great drumming,  took off around 2.18 for me...especially like the out.  Good to have you back amongst us...your distinctive music, posts and character have been missed by a lot of us here.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: Florida Mike on December 03, 2012, 12:12:53 AM
Very stoned drug induced  psychadelic feel. But not impressed with the vocal overall.  Cool vibe though!
 A song platform is there to expand upon for sure...
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: Sevla on December 03, 2012, 08:42:19 AM
Hi guys...liked the vibe. Some good changes here...I like the lift into the chorus section - really effective. Drumming - good live sound and nice and tight. As you already know, the vocals are flat which nearly put me off - glad I kept with it 'cos there's great potential here.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: tina m on December 04, 2012, 12:51:23 PM
i thought this was very nirvana / billy corgan like & you got a great sound on this but i thought the melody line was a bit weak which was a big shame
also it was one of those songs where your waiting for something to happen & i was plumping on a big guitar freakout & i could feel it coming but all i got was your flange pedal turned up to max...which was disapointing
sorry sounding a bit negative here but i think it could realy have been great :)
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: bewarethisboy on December 04, 2012, 02:49:47 PM
I think this is great - put me in mind of Hawkwind  - but good. Only tiny criticism - would have worked better for me if the vocal had been mixed forward in the opening verse - i was struggling a little to get my head around it really - but once it came forward the whole song came together. Very inventive - really enjoyed it BTB.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: S.T.C on December 04, 2012, 02:58:27 PM
"I think this is great - put me in mind of Hawkwind  - but good."

Explain..i love Hawkwind?
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: Dutchbeat on December 04, 2012, 05:47:47 PM
Hi Virus!

we were missing you  :'(

but good you are back, with an excellent recording!!!!



Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: montydog on December 04, 2012, 07:25:38 PM
Great to have you back. I'm having a glass or two of wine while listening to this which helps. It has a surreal feel like something from late period Beatles. Fantastic vocals which have a very effective effect on them(no idea what it is but it works). God knows how long this must have taken to engineer and mix but it is great. Even the drums sound a bit like Ringo. Wonderful right down to the last drop (and the wine is pretty good too). ;D
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: seriousfun on December 04, 2012, 08:57:44 PM
Excellent peice of songwriting, very trippy. I thought the vocal was good but lyrically very thin. Would have liked a few more ascii characters thrown in.  Production wise needs a lot of work. Its a very muddy recording unfortunately and the vocals at the start are almost totally hidden, maybe the bass a tad strong as well.

As a song though I loved it and I am sure its all there just needs a little tweaking to show it off at its best.

Nice Write
Allan.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: ABeautifulVirus on December 05, 2012, 03:23:06 PM
hey humble thanks to all for the listen!  indeed there is absolutely no production on this - i've been mastering out a few other live tracks too as a demo set on the other side of the spectrum from all the highly produced studio stuff i've posted w/ the multi-track vocal harmonies etc/

mistake laden, painfully off key in some places, tons of wiring issues and polarity spikes, no click track, - this is simply more dark, brooding ( perhaps lyrically boring too lol idk seems to work with the 'mood' ) raw and punk in attitude but goth/grunge in delivery. bit of The Cure in there too as pointed out  :)

good to be back on this forum. one of my dogs unexpectedly passed and it messed me up big time for a spell as any animal lover would understand so i took some time off.  then my work schedule got crazy busy w/ new job. but trying to squeeze in art when and where i can!! 
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: montydog on December 05, 2012, 04:43:03 PM
I can really sympathise with you taking time off after your dog unexpectedly died. I lost my first border collie that way and it left me more devastated and in greater pain than losing my parents. Sounds weird but it's the truth.

Great to have you back.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: nooms on December 05, 2012, 06:54:43 PM
lovely trippy feel to this ..interesting & unpredictable , again..
really well played.  quite compresssed and 'itchycoo parked' which is effective but maybe a little claustrophobic ..i’d have liked it to expand wideways if you know what i mean.  but very nice BV
didnt really get a beatley thing this time, for some reason the btrack reminded of a jeff buckley experimental kind of thing and your vocal had a touch of marc bolan in places.
i hope you dont mind either one

Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: man of simple pleasures on December 06, 2012, 08:08:42 PM
hello there, sorry to hear about your dog!
soon as i hear the guitar hear nirvana in there! very trippy vocals! good listen altho not the kinda thing i would get into!
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: RichyRowlatt on December 07, 2012, 11:45:45 PM
Yep, really enjoyed this. Bit trancelike, strong lyric, enjoyed the off pitch vox and loved the backing vox too. Great stuff.

Sorry to hear about your dog too,

Richy.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: andy5544 on December 08, 2012, 12:33:58 AM
nivana and david bowie have had a love child !!

great tune  ;D
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: Florida Mike on December 09, 2012, 06:00:05 PM
ABV - very sorry to hear about your dog, I feel for you. I too am a big animal lover and have a terrific Boston Terrier, look forward to hearing more from you soon...the good news is that since you feel so bad about the loss I will bet you were a terrific friend and master to him, and that's a great thing. Cheers my friend.
Title: Re: "EXTINCT" {live track}
Post by: James Nighthawk on December 14, 2012, 10:34:51 PM
Nirvana, Pumpkins and a touch of your own style here.

Its an odd one. The thin vocal is ropey pitchwise and hard to pick out the words - possible on purpose - so doesn't push the melody at me but its odd and kinda endearing dispite this. And it is very charismatic and lots of emotion in there. The Long flanges are atmospheric but again push me away as much as draw me in. This is definitely a piece with promise (I like the general chord pattern and the arpeggios)

Nice to see you back!